
When You Need a Third Party Management Company (and How to Make the Partnership Work)
11/5/26, 12:00 PM
Article written in partnership with Desert Hospitality Management.
At some point, most hotel owners face a version of the same question: do I need help running this, and if so, what kind of help do I actually need?
The answer depends on where you are in your ownership journey, how involved you want to be day to day, and what your asset requires. Third party management companies exist precisely for those moments when bringing in an expert operator makes more sense than going it alone.
But understanding when to bring one in, how the relationship works, and how to set it up for success is not always straightforward. We engaged our partner Paul Mengacci, CFO of Desert Hospitality and Ghee Alexander, COO of Desert Hospitality, to talk through the dynamics that make these partnerships succeed.
Management Companies vs. Asset Managers: Not the Same Thing
One of the most common points of confusion in hotel ownership is the difference between a third-party management company and an asset manager. The terms get used interchangeably, but they serve very different functions.
A third-party management company runs the hotel. They handle day-to-day operations, staffing, vendor relationships, brand compliance, and financial reporting. They are, in effect, the operator. In most cases the third-party management company is the employer. The owner steps back from the daily-to-day operations and trusts the management company to execute.
An asset manager works on behalf of the owner to protect and grow the value of the investment. They are not running the hotel. They are watching the numbers, holding the management company accountable, evaluating performance against market benchmarks, and making sure the ownership goals stay front and center.
While the Management Company and Asset Manager perform distinct roles, their ultimate goal is identical: maximizing the hotel’s performance and value. The strongest relationships between these two groups operate as true partnerships, grounded in mutual respect for what each brings to the table. The Management Company provides on-the-ground, real-time operational expertise, while the Asset Manager connects that operational execution to broader ownership objectives and long-term asset value. When expectations are clear and communication remains continuous and transparent, this dual dynamic becomes a powerful driver of success.
What a Successful Three-Way Partnership Actually Looks Like
The relationship between an owner, a management company, and a brand is one of the more complex dynamics in hospitality. Three parties, three sets of priorities, and a lot of room for things to go sideways if the foundation is not solid.
But when it works, it really works. The owner is protected. The brand is upheld. The management company has the space to operate and perform. And guests feel the difference.
There are several success stories I could share, but one of the most important factors in any successful three-way partnership is building a strong relationship with the Brand Liaison. Being a strong brand citizen requires a deep understanding of the brand's priorities and ensuring that hotel operations remain aligned with those objectives. To stay ahead of evolving standards and initiatives, our team attends every Brand Conference, Franchise Conference, and Regional Brand event. This commitment keeps us closely connected to the brand's vision and expectations. In many cases, hotels that struggle operationally are not consistently adhering to brand standards or key operational requirements.
A recent example is our management transition of a Marriott hotel. From the outset, we recognized that the hotels required significant operational improvements as well as capital investment. Open and transparent communication among ownership, the brand, and our management team was established on day one and proved essential to the partnership's success.
Ownership demonstrated a strong commitment by investing more than $750,000 in immediate property improvements to enhance the guest experience. At the same time, the original Property Improvement Plan (PIP) required extensive renovations to be completed within a year. We recognized that executing a major renovation while simultaneously transforming hotel operations would place excessive strain on the team and potentially jeopardize long-term success.
Working collaboratively with the brand, we successfully negotiated an extension of the renovation timeline and restructured the project into two phases. This approach allowed us to prioritize operational excellence, strengthen service delivery, and build a sustainable culture of accountability before undertaking the full renovation program.
The results have been exceptional. Within one year, we established a strong service culture, increased revenue by more than 30% compared to the previous year, and earned the confidence of ownership to invest beyond the original PIP requirements. Today, the hotel is positioned for continued growth and success.
Most importantly, all three stakeholders benefited: ownership achieved stronger financial performance, the brand gained a more compliant and competitive property, and the hotel team now has the resources and culture necessary to deliver an outstanding guest experience. That alignment of trust, communication, and shared commitment is what made the partnership successful.
What made the partnership click?
Early and transparent communication among management, ownership, and the brand.
Mutual trust and a willingness to collaborate on solutions rather than simply enforce requirements.
Ownership's commitment to investing in the asset.
A shared focus on long-term success rather than short-term compliance.
Flexibility from the brand to adjust the renovation timeline based on operational realities.
Consistent engagement with brand leadership and a strong understanding of brand priorities.
What Real Alignment Requires
Alignment between owners, management companies, and brands gets talked about constantly. It is also, in practice, one of the hardest things to get right.
True alignment is not just a signed contract and a kick-off call. It is shared expectations, clear communication channels, and a mutual understanding of what success looks like and who is accountable for what. It requires honesty on the front end, even when the conversations are uncomfortable.
Balancing Profitability, Performance, and Brand Standards
Every hotel owner wants strong returns. Every management company wants the freedom to operate well. Every brand wants its standards upheld. In a perfect world, those three things reinforce each other. In reality, they can pull in different directions.
Profitability demands lean operations and smart revenue strategy. Performance benchmarks keep you honest against the market. Brand standards protect the guest experience and the flag on the door. The art of a good management company is holding all three at once without letting any one of them collapse under the weight of the others.
Successfully navigating competing priorities requires a combination of data-driven decision-making, strategic alignment, and complete transparency among all stakeholders. Within our organization, we evaluate hotel performance through a balanced scorecard that includes revenue growth, market share, profitability, guest satisfaction, brand compliance, and associate engagement. We do not view success through a single lens; a hotel that excels financially but struggles with guest satisfaction or brand standards is not truly a high-performing asset. Sustainable success requires balance across all key performance indicators.
Benchmarking our hotels against one another creates healthy internal competition and helps identify best practices that can be shared throughout the portfolio. However, when priorities among ownership, the brand, and hotel operations begin to diverge, transparent communication becomes the most important management tool we have.
As hotel operators, it is critical to provide an honest assessment of where a property stands today and where it needs to go in the future. We have assumed management of hotels that were underperforming in both market share and guest satisfaction while also struggling with brand compliance.
In those situations, our responsibility is to clearly communicate the property's current performance, establish realistic expectations, and present a comprehensive plan for improvement. Both the long-term vision and short-term strategies must be clearly articulated so that ownership, the brand, and the hotel team remain aligned and confident in the path forward.
A recent example involved a property where the brand was advocating for an accelerated renovation schedule, while ownership preferred to delay the investment. Our role was to bridge those competing priorities and identify a solution that served everyone's interests.
The hotel was already a top performer within the brand, consistently earning recognition for exceptional guest satisfaction scores and overall operational excellence. Through a series of collaborative discussions, we were able to demonstrate the hotel's strong performance metrics and long-standing track record. Ultimately, the brand agreed to remove the renovation requirement, recognizing that the guest experience and brand standards were already being delivered at an exceptionally high level.
This outcome exemplifies what balance looks like in practice. It is not about choosing the brand's priorities over ownership's objectives, or vice versa. It is about understanding the interests of each stakeholder, communicating openly, supporting decisions with data, and finding solutions that protect the long-term success of the asset.
When trust, transparency, and strong operational performance are in place, it becomes much easier to align competing priorities and achieve positive outcomes for everyone involved.
About Desert Hospitality
Desert Hospitality Management (DHM) is a hotel management company with a growing portfolio of branded hotels and resorts across the United States. They specialize in operating high-performing properties by combining hands-on leadership, innovative solutions, local market insight, and a people-first approach. Focused on the American hospitality market, we partner with ownership groups to elevate performance, enhance guest satisfaction, and deliver long-term value.